Benjamin GARTHWAIT
Daniel RAY
Phebe Viola CRANDALL

Husband-1:  Benjamin GARTHWAIT
Birth:   1812, Marcellus, Onondaga Co., New York
Death:  Aft 1870, Rock Co., Wisconsin
Burial:
Father:  Daniel GARTHWAIT
Mother:  Esther JEFFERS

Marriage-1:   1834, Allegany Co., New York

Husband-2:  Daniel RAY
Birth:  Sep 1814, New York
Death:  1911, Ceres, McKean Co., Pennsylvania
Burial:
Father:  
Mother:  

Marriage-2:   Bef 1870, Allegany Co., New York

Wife:  Phebe Viola CRANDALL
Birth:  1816, Alfred, Allegany Co., New York
Death:   Abt 1878, Bolivar, Allegany Co., New York
Burial:  
Father:  Christopher CRANDALL  
Mother:  Clarinda GALUSHA

Children - Marriage-1:
1. Christopher C. GARTHWAIT, b: 27 Dec 1835, Alfred, Allegany Co., New York
2. Daniel Benjamin GARTHWAIT, b: 23 Apr 1843, Alfred, Allegany Co., New York
                                                      d: (Civil War) 23 Dec 1862, Washington D.C.  
3. Isaac P. GARTHWAIT, b: 10 Sep 1845, Alfred, Allegany Co., New York
4. Caroline D. GARTHWAIT, b: May 1849, Alfred, Allegany Co., New York
5. Lorenzo P. GARTHWAIT, b: 13 Mar 1851, Bolivar, Allegany Co., New York
6. Luanna D. GARTHWAIT, b: Jun 1854, Bolivar, Allegany Co., New York
7. Fred Eugene GARTHWAIT, b: 28 Oct 1857, Bolivar, Allegany Co., New York
__________
Notes:
Benjamin's brother, Jacob, married Phebe's sister, Clarinda.

1850 Federal Census Data (M432_0475, Page 46), Bolivar, Allegany Co., New York,
                                                                                                              Enumeration Date: 19-Nov-1850, Family #116

1860 Federal Census Data (M653_0717, Page 254) Bolivar, Allegany Co., New York,
                                                                                                                      Enumeration Date: 19-Jul-1860, Family #330

Some researchers show Benjamin leaving the family in New York, moving to Wisconsin and remarrying.  Phebe married again before 1870.

1870 Federal Census Data (M593_0904, Page 487A), Bolivar, Allegany Co., New York,
                                                                                                                          Enumeration Date: 4-Aug-1870, Family #171

_________
Sources:
Elder John Crandall of Rhode Island and His Descendants; by John Cortland Crandall; Higginson Book Co.; 1949